India Wary of Trump-Xi-Putin Summit: What are New Delhi’s concerns?
India foreign policy, US Russia China relations: India remains cautious as Trump, Putin and Xi reportedly hold a landmark trilateral meeting, raising questions about the future global power balance.
Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping at a table amid discussions over a possible shift in global power dynamics.
As a new world order seems to be emerging, with the U.S. on one side and Russia and China on the other, the rare three-way meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping has caused a lot of talk in international diplomatic circles. The meeting took place on Thursday (19 November) on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen, China. While it has received significant international attention due to talks on the redistribution of power in the world, nuclear security, energy resources and reform in the United Nations, India is taking its time commenting on this new development. New Delhi said it will not make any comments, until further details are known regarding what decisions were made in the meeting.
India's Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said that New Delhi was aware of a meeting between the heads of state of three APEC nations but more information will be required on what happened for an assessment to be made. Therefore it appears that India will not take a stance either way for the time being.
In international politics, the US, China, and Russia are three very influential nations. Whilst relations between Washington and Beijing are tense due to both economic and strategic rivalry, relations between the US and Russia have been difficult for many years due to the war in Ukraine. Therefore, the meeting between the heads of state of these three nations have caused questions to be raised regarding whether there may be a new balance of power in international politics.
According to reports, a joint declaration issued after the meeting mentioned cooperation on matters including lowering nuclear risks, safeguarding energy security, and reforming the United Nations. The three leaders restated that a nuclear war can never be won and should never be fought. The talks also underscored the need to make the United Nations more effective at upholding international peace and security.
Yet, not withstanding the importance of the meeting, no major breakthrough was achieved regarding the wars in Ukraine and Iran. No new agreement or specific timetable on nuclear arms control was announced either. This has prompted questions about how much practical change the meeting will really deliver, despite its political importance.
The meeting has likewise sparked discussion among India's political circles. Certain Opposition leaders have raised questions about why India was absent from a gathering that included the heads of three major global powers. At a moment when a new international power balance may be taking shape, concerns have also been voiced about whether India's absence might impact its diplomatic standing. In reply, the Ministry of External Affairs has cited the Quad summit that took place earlier this week.
India has long maintained defence and energy ties with Russia. At the same time, cooperation with the United States in trade, technology and defence continues to matter to New Delhi. Even though India and China share a history of border tensions and strategic rivalry, their economic relationship remains significant. Any new understanding among these three powers could thus affect India's foreign policy, economy and national security.
In particular, a possible understanding between Washington and Moscow on the Ukraine war could reduce the pressure of potential US sanctions or extra tariffs on India for buying Russian energy. Likewise, an improvement in US-China relations could shift the balance of power in the Indo-Pacific region. Until now, the rivalry between Washington and Beijing has enhanced India's strategic importance. New Delhi is therefore watching closely how any potential agreement between the two countries might alter this equation.
India has consistently championed a multipolar world order. Put differently, New Delhi holds that global politics should not be dominated by one or a few powerful nations. Rather, various countries should play a meaningful role in international decision-making. Viewed in this light, a unique arrangement among the United States, China and Russia might not necessarily be a favorable development for India.
For the time being, then, India is hesitant to draw any conclusions from the Trump, Xi and Putin meeting. New Delhi is closely monitoring the real results of the talks and how far they might reshape global politics.
